Since Animal Crossing New Horizons is still fairly new and absolutely everyone is still playing the game, we thought it’d be appropriate to do an Animal Crossing edition of would you rather. So, Kris, would you rather have terraforming and not be allowed to move anything once it’s already placed (houses, trees, etc.) or not have terraforming but be able to move anything and rearrange your island however you wanted?
I believe I would like the ability to be able to move and rearrange my island without the terraforming. It would be a challenge to use the island layout when arranging everything to my liking. Rachel, would you rather always be surprised with the villagers that move into your island (or town) or need to always pick them and choose them, getting rid of that surprise element entirely?
I would rather always be surprised. I’m surprised I’ve been island hopping to find a certain someone, especially because I like the element of surprise and I do want to collect them all at some point. The surprise makes it more fun. If Animal Crossing had a new side game come out, would you rather be a real estate agent under Tom Nook (though not like Happy Home Designer) or be a museum curator and work under Blathers?
I’d work with Tom Nook. I’d bet I’d make bank! That and, as interesting as the collecting and facts about the items in the museum are, the museum isn’t as appealing to me. Blathers is cool, though. Being a real estate agent, trying to persuade buyers, find hidden gems among houses, sounds like it can be fun! Would you rather have all the clothing options for your character or would you like to be able to decorate the houses and buildings of your island or town? Basically, fashion or interior design?
I think I’d prefer the latter. I absolutely love the fashion options in New Horizons – they added and upgraded so much. However, you can only go so far when it comes to changing outfits. There are a ton of interior decorating items and collections to mix and match – plus, you have multiple rooms to try out many different things at once and switch them up here and there. Would you rather have all your villagers be the same species at random (for example, have an entire island with chicken villagers) or would you rather have all your villagers be one specific personality type at random (for example, all cranky villagers)?
I don’t think I’d mind a random species with different personalities. I think it’s the personalities that really make the characters. As long as each character looked different enough for me to tell them apart at a glance, I’d pick having the different personalities. Would you rather have only one island or town that is super large, giving you plenty of space but may be overwhelming with taking care of the whole thing, or have the ability to have multiple small islands or towns, perhaps only with enough room for one specialty shop and a handful of villagers?
I’d rather have something large. As much as I’d love to have multiple islands, if I’d have to put the museum on one island and the shop on the other, it wouldn’t be as worth it. Final question from me, would you rather only play Animal Crossing for the Gamecube for the rest of your life or only play Animal Crossing New Leaf – no, that’s not a typo – for the rest of your life?
No New Horizons then? Between those two, I’d probably go with New Leaf. It has more updated mechanics and graphics. Not saying that the simpler Gamecube would be bad, but I think New Leaf has more to offer and may hold my attention longer. For your last question to answer, would you rather only be able to play New Horizons without online play or always be online with your gates open for friends?
Great, make people get mad at me… I’d rather have no online play. Being able to send letters to friends and have them come onto my island is fabulous, but I’m too much of a control freak. I wouldn’t want to share my deserted island with anyone. Overall, I think we came up with some pretty good questions based on Animal Crossing. Maybe part two will come at some point!